Harriet Owen Hughes – Our Meticulous Paintings Conservator

Of all the crafts which have been involved in the restoration of the Abbey, perhaps the most intricate has been the work of paintings conservation. This has been undertaken by Harriet Owen Hughes at The Conservation Centre in Liverpool, which is part of the National Museums Liverpool.

Harriet first worked on a painting from Combermere several years ago, and conserved the four Tudor portraits from the fire surround in The Library six years ago. Of these portraits she says that she found the royal portraits to be “set pieces”, that is to say replicas of existing images of Henry and Elizabeth. Both monarchs were keen that their image should be seen throughout the land and many copies were made of portraits for which they had actually sat. On the other and the portrait of Richard Cotton’s son and heir, George, was far more interesting, “He looked much more like a real person. The others had been messed about with; that one is the most genuine”, she says. You can read more about these portraits by clicking here. The fire surround portraits were conserved with the help of a grant from the Heritage Conservation Trust.

The painting of Elizabeth had been ‘updated’ at least once, it seemed, possibly once in the reign of Queen Anne, to make the Tudor monarch look more contemporary; indeed, possibly to make her look like Queen Anne. There was “something else” under Elizabeth I’s ruff, Harriet thought, but it did not show up in x-rays, and it was probably a completely different ruff (and a different dead dress). It would have been wrong to take the restoration any further back. “I would have liked to have got the dendrochronology man in and have dated the wood on which the portraits were painted, but in fact we couldn’t, which was a shame – so we can’t be entirely sure that they were contemporaneous with the re-building of the house”.

The most recent project which Harriet has undertaken for the Abbey was the large bird’s-eye view of the estate by Tillemans, painted in 1730, and the larger and later portraits from the Library. The Tillemans painting was worked on in Harriet’s studio from October 2014 until that Christmas. You can see more about the Tillemans and its restoration by clicking here.

One portrait, an almost-full-size painting of a mid-Seventeenth century gentleman in armour, was found to have been extended downwards at some point. The legs were not there originally, and a panel had been attached for their creation, but what was really surprising was that, under the latter paint, there had been a much earlier and rather good painting of some flowers. This panel had been attached upside down. A decision was made to conserve the flowers around his armoured legs so that he now stands in an herbaceous border, which is rather curious but does give us the best of both worlds.

That portrait, and one of a continental – possibly Dutch or German – lady were in poor repair, and Harriet thinks that they might previously have been heavily restored after a fire, or some similar major catastrophe.

One problem encountered on a number of the Combermere paintings, and apparently a very common one, was that they had been over-cleaned in the past – often on more than one occasion – and then there was too much over-painting, creating headaches for later conservators; “Any re-touching I have done is made up of a mixture of pigments and varnish, so in the future it can be taken off as easily as taking off varnish. We are very particular about varnish; we make our own from resin. It doesn’t go yellow and it is reversible.”

Harriet began her career by studying Art History at the Courtauld Institute, (where her tutors included Sir Anthony Blunt, who was later exposed as a Soviet spy, and was stripped of his knighthood) and then took a two-year course in conservation in the same building. She moved to Liverpool when she married and worked at the Walker Art Gallery, before setting up her own conservation studio in the Bluecoat Chambers in the city.

The facilities in her current studio at the Conservation Centre, where she has now been for fifteen years, are world class, she says. The Centre was opened by Prince Charles some twenty years ago, but in recent years it has been hard hit by cuts in funding.

We are very grateful to Harriet for her superb work in giving new life to all the Abbey paintings she has worked on.

You can read more about the portraits in The Library and the restoration story by clicking here.

Early March 2015 And The New Roof Timbers Are In Place

 The first week of March 2015 saw clear, bright weather for the most part, and it won’t be long before the roof on the North Wing can be clad and made water-tight. The protective tent and the huge amount of supportive scaffolding can then be removed and work will continue within the building.  There is still a lot of work to do within the building, and the joiners are leading the way at the moment.

2015-03-02 14.51.02

 The original, decayed roof was taken off completely and the new timbers have now been bolted into place. This shot was taken from the north-west corner, with the lake off to the right.

2015-03-02 14.51.15

 On the front facing the lake the crenellations, created during the gothicisation of the house in the early-Nineteenth century, are being re-created. The timber work seen here is the basic form for the mock battlements . . . 

2015-03-02 14.51.25

This will then be edged with specially-made glass-fibre copings, which reflect the original profile. These will deflect wind and rain more effectively than the poorly-made original fixtures ever did.

2015-03-02 14.51.44

 A simple plywood template follows the rising contour of the roof as it rises in the centre of the roof-line, and the crenellation is then built to this profile.

2015-03-02 14.51.59

 Modern building regulations apply even to Grade i listed buildings, and insulation is put in place to meet the standards required by law. It is unlikely that the local authority buildings inspector who will be required to sign off the Abbey when work is complete will has ever had to certify quite such an august building.

2015-03-02 14.52.31

 The new timbers have been erected inside the rotten Tudor timbers, which so desperately needed to be replaced. When the new frame is complete the old wood can be completely removed.

2015-03-02 14.52.50

The chimneys on the North Wing were re-created to exactly match those that had to be demolished. They were built first and the roof’s timber work was created around them.

2015-03-02 14.53.34

 On the east face of the house, where there was less damage to the existing structure, the gothick fenestration details have been created, and the wall has been rendered. New flashing protects the horizontal upper ledge from the weather.

2015-03-02 14.54.01

The gutters is offset inside the structure of the house, and new flashing has been cut and moulded – in ways which Tudor craftsmen would recognise – to channel rain and snow safely away.

2015-03-02 14.55.11

2015-03-02 14.57.53

 The main staircase is being created; this view is from the ground floor. It will lead right up to the top of the building.

2015-03-02 15.01.55

 Made off-site by heritage craftsmen, the new hardwood window frames exactly reproduce the design of the windows put in two hundred years ago for the first Viscount Combermere’s gothicisation project.

The Man On The Carpet

Had you been walking through Combermere Abbey recently you might have been startled to see a gentleman of a certain age laying on the floor on his side, with his head resting on the carpet. You would have been forgiven for thinking that the poor chap had suffered a seizure of some kind, but closer examination would have revealed the unlikely truth that in fact he was peering at the wainscoting. His name is Icaro Kosak and he has been responsible for specialist paint detailing at the Abbey, and decorative paint techniques.

2014-12-03 15.47.09

“It’s the vacuum cleaners”, he said, “No matter how careful the cleaners are their vacuum cleaners still take chunks out of the paint”. So there he was, with a fine brush and a carefully-mixed colour, re-touching work that he first created quite some time ago. Many years ago he created a wood grain on the wainscoting, and now repairs were needed.

As we have reported elsewhere, the larger armorial shields on the coving in The Library were fitted on a ground which had a grained effect. This was disturbed in places by Hare & Humphreys excellent restoration work, and now Icaro had been called in to make good – and to tour the Abbey doing any repairs to his work which were needed.

He applied a ‘ground’ colour to the background coving, which is plasterboard, and then created an artificial wood-grained effect as a top coat. There had been some staining in the base material, but Icaro’s work evened that out and a single, uninterrupted effect was achieved. His medium is an oil-based artists’ oil paint.

Two decades ago Icaro created the individual decoration in the Abbey’s self-catering cottages, and also worked in the Abbey itself – on the hall, the staircase, and any number of other rooms which cried out for paint detail. He describes his work as ‘specialist decorations’, which ranges from marbling to trompe l’oeil murals.

Born in Rome but now living in south London, Icaro drew and painted from an early age, and has specialised in interior design and paintwork for more than three decades. He has worked in commercial and retail properties as well as in homes both large and small, and both ancient and modern.

He was full of praise for the recent restoration of The Library ceiling; “It’s beautiful, quite beautiful. It doesn’t look restored, doesn’t look new, which is very difficult to achieve. I’m very glad to see it.”

He was only at the Abbey for three days on this visit; “I go very fast when I get going”, he says. He went on, “I love this house. Wherever you look you see a different century – there’s always something else to see. I was first here in 1990, and I have seen a lot of changes, all for the better. It’s unbelievable how much work and effort has gone into the restoration here. Very impressive.”

2014-12-03 15.32.16

Icaro’s temporary work bench, with the tools of his trade

Lots More New Wood

The weather has continued to be very kind to the restoration of the North Wing at Combermere abbey. Even though the entire Wing is covered in a temporary ‘tent’, bad weather would make conditions on the ground very difficult. As it is there have been no interruptions to the proceedings, and the team has had a very good autumn.

Combermere library and north wing may 12 072

The bare earth on the ground floor is now covered (as you can see in the photo below), and is ready for the installations of high-efficiency underfloor heating. A small section of what may be medieval stone flooring was discovered, and has been chronicled, but that aside there were no exciting discoveries.

The Abbey has nothing in the way of cellars – in fact it hardly has anything in the way of foundations. When the ground floor floorboards come up the earth is only a few inches below. So much so that moles have been known to come up through the floorboards inside the house!

2014-10-28 19.15.34The story throughout the rest of the North Wing is of more new timber going in. As we’ve seen in earlier posts, a lot of rotten, original wood has had to be removed, and the joiners have cut new pieces to replace them. And  replicated them beautifully, it must be said. Some of the larger pieces have been bolted into position with very chunky, steel fasteners, but in most areas the new wood is held in place with wooden pegs, just as it would have been hundreds of years ago. It’s a simple and efficient method, and it worked well in Tudor times and it works equally well nowadays.

The photographs below show the new roof structure at the most easterly corner of the Wing, and how the new joinery mates to the Sixteenth century timber-work. As noted before, the very handsome, fluted chimney was taken down as far as was necessary and has now been rebuilt with new, local bricks, exactly in its original profile.

The modern, bright yellow, joiners’ bench saw would have stunned the men who worked in wood at the Abbey five hundred years ago. They did everything ‘the hard way’, as we see it nowadays.

2014-10-28 19.18.15

2014-10-28 19.18.30

2014-10-28 19.20.11

2014-10-28 19.21.28

2014-10-28 19.23.01

2014-10-28 19.23.34

2014-10-28 19.24.20

2014-10-28 19.25.59More brickwork has gone into place, and on external walls the original gothick arrow slits have been replicated, as the photo below shows.

2014-10-28 19.18.56Some meteorologists are forecasting a severe winter, which will be no fun for the workers, but we can only wait and see. Certainly though that is when the tent will earn its keep.